Safaricom's Stock Market Story in Ethiopia

From M- Pessa to Missed Calls!

Seizing Opportunities, Navigating Risks: Safaricom's Stock Market Story in Ethiopia

This encounter got me thinking about Safaricom's recent foray into the Ethiopian telecom market. When the company was granted a license to operate in Ethiopia, investors were incredibly optimistic. They envisioned Safaricom replicating its Kenyan success in a country with more than twice the population, introducing M-Pesa to millions of unbanked Ethiopians, and easily outcompeting Ethio Telecom and Telle Birr with its superior operational efficiency, customer service and brand reputation as key competitive advantages. This bullish sentiment of investors drove Safaricom Kenya’s stock price to soar, nearing its all-time high of around 45 KES at Nairobi Stock Exchange. Investors were eager to capitalize on what they perceived as a guaranteed success story.

However, as we know, Safaricom's Ethiopian journey has been anything but smooth. Safaricom's expansion into Ethiopia has been hampered by a multitude of challenges. These include regulatory hurdles that slowed the rollout of key services, fierce competition from the incumbent operator, Ethio Telecom, and economic and political instability within Ethiopia, including internal conflicts, high inflation, and currency devaluation. Furthermore, building the necessary infrastructure across Ethiopia's vast and diverse terrain has proven to be a costly and time-consuming endeavor. Adding to the complexity, the unexpected departure of the initial CEO created uncertainty, while regional tensions, including boycotts in Oromya region and a state of emergency in Amhara region, further complicated Safaricom's expansion efforts.

The Rise and Fall (and Rise?)

of Safaricom Stock.

In June 2021, anticipation for Safaricom's Ethiopian launch reached fever pitch, with the share price hitting KES 45. This optimism stemmed from the potential of tapping into a market with over 110 million people (source: World Bank) and replicating the success of M-Pesa, Safaricom's mobile money juggernaut.

However, by September 28, 2024, the share price had plummeted to KES 15.00 (source: Nairobi Securities Exchange), a stark contrast to the initial exuberance. This decline reflects the challenges Safaricom has encountered in Ethiopia, a fall by 67%.

This decline reflects the impact of market realities and investor sentiment on a company's valuation, even when operating in a high-potential market like Ethiopia.

So, does this mean Safaricom's Ethiopian venture is doomed to fail? Or is this a temporary setback on the road to long-term success? How should investors interpret these challenges and adjust their expectations? We'll get deeper into these questions and analyze the future prospects of Safaricom’s stock price. This article examines Safaricom's Ethiopian venture from a stock market perspective, analyzing the factors that have influenced its performance and offering insights for investors. Stay tuned!

Is Safaricom Stock Undervalued or a Strong Buy?

Based on both the technical and fundamental analysis of Safaricom Kenya, investors should approach the stock with cautious optimism.

From technical perspective, currently, Safaricom’s stock is displaying a death cross, where its 50-day moving average (15.60 KES) has fallen below its 200-day moving average (16.80 KES). This is typically a bearish signal, indicating that the stock may experience further downward pressure in the short term. However, this may also present a buying opportunity if the stock stabilizes and shows signs of a reversal, potentially moving towards a golden cross where the 50-day average crosses above the 200-day average, signaling a bullish trend.

From a fundamental perspective, Safaricom appears to be undervalued. Its P/E ratio of 9.44 is well below its historical average of 19.22 and lower than its peer group, suggesting it is trading at a discount. Additionally, its EV/EBITDA ratio of 4.36 is also below the sector average of 6.33, reinforcing the idea that the stock is undervalued relative to its earnings potential. While Safaricom's revenue growth rate has slowed, with earnings declining by around 15%, the company remains a dominant player in the telecom sector, particularly with its M-Pesa mobile money service, which offers long-term growth potential.

For investors looking to approach Safaricom Kenya, several key suggestions emerge from both the technical and fundamental analysis. First, value-oriented investors should consider Safaricom an attractive opportunity due to its significant undervaluation. With its Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio at 9.44, well below its historical average of 19.22 and lower than its peer group, the stock is trading at a discount. Additionally, its Enterprise Value to EBITDA (EV/EBITDA) ratio of 4.36, compared to the sector average of 6.33, further reinforces its potential as an undervalued asset. These metrics suggest that the stock is priced below its fair value, making it a strong candidate for investors with a long-term view.

For growth-oriented investors, while Safaricom’s recent revenue growth has slowed, with a decline in earnings of about 15%, the company’s dominant market position in Kenya and its cash-generating mobile money service, M-Pesa, offer solid long-term growth potential. Despite the short-term slowdown, investors should remain optimistic about Safaricom’s ability to rebound as the Kenyan economy and its digital services sector expand.

On the technical front, short-term traders should exercise caution. The current death cross—where the 50-day moving average has fallen below the 200-day moving average—signals potential further downside. However, this also provides a possible entry point if the stock stabilizes or shows signs of a reversal, which could lead to a golden cross and signal a bullish trend.

In conclusion, while short-term volatility may persist, Safaricom’s strong fundamentals and undervaluation relative to its peers make it a stock worth considering for long-term investment. Investors should watch for signs of recovery in both the technical and growth outlooks before making aggressive moves.

Investor Sentiment and

Market Realities

The sharp decline in Safaricom's stock price underscores the disconnect between initial market expectations and the on-the-ground realities in Ethiopia. While the long-term potential remains, investors are reassessing their valuations in light of these challenges.

Safaricom's Ethiopian venture underscores key takeaways for investors: the necessity of thorough due diligence and realistic risk assessment before investing in companies expanding into new markets; the importance of a long-term perspective, recognizing that building a successful business in a new environment takes time and resilience to overcome setbacks; and the critical need for companies to be agile and adaptable when facing unforeseen challenges in volatile markets. Ultimately, Safaricom's experience serves as a valuable case study, highlighting the complexities of investing in emerging economies like Ethiopia. While the potential rewards are significant, navigating the political, economic, and operational landscape requires careful consideration and a long-term commitment

.

Dr. Abush Ayalew is a passionate advocate for financial literacy and empowerment. He holds an MBA in Finance from Lincon University (Gold Medalist) and has years of experience in the global stock market. He is the founder of Adwa Transformation Center, an online platform dedicated to providing accessible and practical financial education. Dr. Abush is also the author of several books on finance and investing. He believes that everyone has the potential to achieve financial freedom through knowledge and strategic action.

Ready to deepen your understanding of investment strategies and market dynamics? Enroll in our comprehensive stock market courses at Adwa Transformation Center and gain the knowledge and skills to navigate the complexities of the financial world with confidence!